This study aims to help the setting up of a service to provide well-calibrated measurements of drifting buoy sea surface temperature (SST), using traceable standards.
The Towards fiducial Reference measUrements of Sea-Surface Temperature by European Drifters (TRUSTED) project contributes to the necessary infrastructure for Fiducial Reference Measurements (FRM) needed for the validation of high resolution and high accuracy satellite Sea Surface Temperature (SST) from the Copernicus Sentinel-3 Sea and Land Surface Temperature Radiometer (SLSTR).
This is achieved by providing measurements from a significant number of drifting buoys equipped with additional digital SST probes, to the usual design, in order to achieve a better calibrated capability. These also incorporate the most recent geo-location accuracy and position reporting and time reporting capability. Assessment of these drifting buoy SST measurements for SLSTR SST validation, will be achieved through scientific quality control within the project, and planned Sentinel-3 validation activities.
The purpose of the TRUSTED project is to set up a service to "provide well-calibrated drifting buoy SST, towards SI-traceable standards, HRSST-FRM", so that it is then possible to "assess and establish the benefit of improved capability of HRSST-2 drifting buoys for satellite SST validation". Further assessment is planned as part of the activities for Copernicus Sentinel-3 SLSTR Validation.
The project incorporates scientific quality control and analysis of the drifting buoy measurements. The project aims to provide measurements from 100–150 drifting buoys with an improved capability (HRSST-2) and assess their quality in coordination with EUMETSAT and the wider international community.
In the future satellites with even more stringent requirements are expected, including for coastal applications, and those with higher spatial resolutions. Therefore, this project is relevant in the long term for the whole satellite SST constellation.
Coordination of the satellite SST community with the Data Buoy Cooperation Panel (DBCP) continues and is a new way of working and, if successful, may extend to other Essential Climate Variables (ECVs). These new measurements are essential, not only for satellite validation activities in order to ensure the quality of the SLSTR SST products for the users, but also to contribute to algorithm development, and to lead to further necessary improvements.
EUMETSAT needs FRM to deliver the required confidence in the Copernicus data products for users, as outlined in the CEOS Quality Assurance framework for Earth Observation (QA4EO), so it is possible to understand the uncertainties, and how accurate the data products are through full traceability. These FRM measurements protocols are intended to be fully traceable, documented, and long term.
Earth Observation programmes aim to provide the scientific community with continuous, large scale datasets. Whereas, the in situ observation network provides datasets limited either in time or in space (often high frequency punctual measurements over a short period of time), space-borne Earth Observation systems can provide long term and, often, global datasets, although generally with a lower sampling frequency (usually daily).
Space-borne Earth Observation systems also have the advantage of being able to provide data everywhere, regardless of accessibility issues (geophysical or political), and, for some sensors, regardless of meteorological conditions. In recent years, in part due to the increase in the number of sensors being in flown, but also because of the efforts put into inter sensor and inter mission calibration, these datasets have become ubiquitous.
Of particular interest to oceanographers and meteorologists is the acquisition of high quality sea surface temperature (SST) data. Over short time scales, this state variable provides important information on the spatial distribution and intensity of dynamic structures such as eddies, coastal currents, and upwelling region in near real time (down to a few hours after acquisition). Long-term datasets (going back almost four decades) can also provide information on global and regional sea surface temperature trends, which can be used to monitor the evolution of the surface ocean on decadal time scales, and help quantify the intensity of events such as El Niño/La Niña. Both sets of data, long term and short, are critical to the calibration and validation of weather and climate models that provide crucial information on forthcoming climate trends. Furthermore, SST data is a key input to all weather and climate model assimilation schemes, which limits model drift and, hence, improves the quality of forecasts.
The importance of monitoring SST is generally accepted by the oceanographic and meteorological scientific communities. An SST sensor was included in the EU Copernicus-funded Sentinel-3 Earth Observation mission, namely the Sentinel Land Sea Surface Thermal Radiometer (SLSTR) which is flown on the Sentinel-3A and -3B satellites. This sensor has the particularity of being dual view, meaning higher quality SST observations are possible, accounting better for water vapour and aerosol, in addition to the two onboard black body calibration capability. It’s also useful for reference purposes when combined with other satellite SST data, as a continuation from AATSR. This is necessary to ensure the continuity with past SST missions.
However, in order to achieve the desired quality of Earth Observation measurements, the Sentinel-3 SLSTR sensor needs to be calibrated to the highest level. Such a calibration requires the highest possible quality FRM/in situ data for validation. This, in effect, means high quality data and high quality data distribution, both in terms of spatial and time coverage.
As a result, the Copernicus programme is funding a series of dedicated FRM initiatives. These FRM initiatives aim to collect new sets of measurements that are traceable, long term, and calibrated to SI, bringing a high level of quality to oceanography in situ measurements. Among them is the deployment of an array of temperature measuring surface drifters through the Towards fiducial Reference measUrements of Sea-Surface Temperature by European Drifters (TRUSTED) project.
The TRUSTED project team, led by CLS, includes NKE Instrumentation, who are designing and building the buoys; the SHOM (the Naval Hydrographic and Oceanographic Service), which is in charge of calibration; Météo-France, which will look after deployment; BSH (the Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency of Germany) which will provide a tethered reference measurement, and JCOMMOPS (WMO-IOC Joint Technical Commission for Oceanography and Marine Meteorology's In-situ Observing Program's Support Center), which will provide the metadata processing and visualisation tools to monitor the deployments.
During Phase1, which ended in June 2018, the SVP-BRST was developed and two prototypes were built and strenuously tested. The drifters carry temperature sensors, one analog (SST) and one digital (HR-SST), a barometer, a strain gauge, and an iridium modem, allowing them to send back observation data in near real time. Each component of the buoys, as well as the buoys as a whole, were tested either in tanks in the workshop, in a quarry nearby, or out at sea in various weather conditions. This was to ensure that the new buoys met the stringent standards defined by the Data Buoy Cooperation Panel, ensuring that the data collected during the lifetime of the project, and beyond, can be incorporated in the global databases such as the GTS (Global telecommunication System).
A core part of phase 1 was the metrology testing to insure that the new instrument, namely the HR-SST sensor, was tested and calibrated to SI standards. In effect the digital sensor was first calibrated by itself and then within the buoy casing in the SHOM metrology laboratory. The results from the metrology exceeded the project aims, with an error below the 0.01 °C threshold. The buoys were then loaded on the SHOM research vessel Beautemps-Beaupre which was headed for the western Mediterranean. For good measure, the buoys were first put to sea but tethered to the vessel in conjunction with an SI referenced instrument, the SBE 35 installed below a Multi Bottle Sampling Array (MBSA) belonging to the SHOM and immersed just below the surface. Both sets of measurements were then compared to check the accuracy of the sensor. The buoys were finally deployed in the Balearic Sea, south west of Majorca, simultaneously on the 25 April at 22:55 UTC. The location chosen was within an eddy in order to minimise the risk of grounding, always a possibility in enclosed seas such as the Mediterranean. The buoys stayed within the eddy and very close to each other for the first 23 days. After that, they separated and one ran aground on the Algerian coast, just east of the city of Amara (Figure 2).
During the second phase, which started in summer 2018, a further 100 buoys will be built and delivered in two batches. They will then be deployed globally over an 18 month period, following a deployment plan set up by Météo-France. The aim is to deploy the buoys in areas particularly well suited to satellite data calibration/validation issues, such as areas with little or no cloud cover. Deploying so many buoys and ensuring the traceability of each instrument and dataset requires careful planning and monitoring. To this end, the project will rely on the JCOMMOPS expertise, and the many tools that it has developed to do just that. This will ensure that end users will have high quality data and meta data at their disposal to allow them to make the best possible use of the data gathered during the project.
The TRUSTED project will provide Copernicus with in situ datasets of the highest quality, towards FRM capability. This will enable the validation of the Sentinel-3 SLSTR sensor, a key step in ensuring that the Copernicus Earth Observation programme meet its ambitious remit and enabling the Sea Surface Temperature data distributed through CMEMS to be continuously improved. Furthermore, the buoy data will also be made available to the global meteorological and oceanographic community as a whole, for analysis, calibration and data assimilation purposes through the GTS, and through the CMEMS data distribution portal, ensuring that these Copernicus-funded drifters benefit the wider scientific community as a whole.
|WP1000||Specification of new drifting buoy design (Phase 1)|
|WP1100||Management and coordination|
|WP1200||Buoy prototype design|
|WP1300||Prototype deployment and data services|
|WP2000||Building and deployment of new drifters, measurement service and data analysis (Phase 2)|
|WP2100||Management and coordination|
|WP2300||Deployment and recovery|
|WP2400||Series Data Processing|
|WP2500||Scientific activities and FRM traceability|
|OWP1500||Provision of GPS quality OPT-010|
|OWP2800||1 Hz Sampling OPT-020|
|OWP2900||Additional 50 drifters OPT-030|
I. Tomazic, A O’Carroll, G. Corlett, J.F. Piolle, EUMETSAT SLSTR sea surface temperature multi-mission matchup database
Lucas, M., TRUSTED - First Data, Sentinel-3 validation team meeting, EUMETSAT, 12 March 2020.
Lucas, M., Project overview of TRUSTED, Sentinel-3 validation team meeting, EUMETSAT, 13-15 March 2018.
Lucas, M., A. David, J. Sagot, P. Poli, M. Belbeoch, K. Herklotz, M. Le Menn, A O’Carroll, TRUSTED: A new generation of drifting buoys: SVP-BRST (Surface Velocity Platform drifter with barometer and reference sensor for temperature, poster for Data Buoy Cooperation Panel meeting, Cape Town, October 2018.
Le Menn, M., P. Poli, A. David, J. Sagot, M. Lucas, A. O’Carroll, M. Belbeoch, K. Herklotz, On the role of metrology in oceanography: the example of TRUSTED project, poster to EOOS conference, Brussels 21-23 November 2018.
M. Lucas TRUSTED FRM: Operational Deployment, presentation to the 5th S3VT meeting, Frascati 7-9 May 2019.
M. Lucas, A. David, J. Sagot, P. Poli, M. Belbeoch, K. Herklotz, M. Le Menn, A. O’Carroll Copernicus TRUSTED: HR-SST in situ datasets, poster to the GHRSST meeting in June 2019.
G. Corlett, A. O’Carroll, I. Tomazic Validation of Copernicus SLSTR SSTs with HRSST drifters
Poli, P., M. Lucas, A. O’Carroll, M. Le Menn, A. David, G.K. Corlett, P. Blouch, D. Meldrum, C.J. Merchant, M. Belbeoch, K. Herklotz, The Copernicus Surface Velocity Platform drifter with Barometer and Reference Sensor for Temperature (CVP-BRST): Genesis, design and initial results
Le Menn, M., P. Poli, A. David, J. Sagot, M. Lucas, A O’Carroll, Development of surface drifting buoys for fiducial reference measurements of sea-surface temperature
https://www.jcommops.org/board (Search -> Platforms -> Programs -> Copernicus HRSST FRM)
|Phase||Date and location|
|AR preparation||29/05/2018, SHOM|
|Review meeting||KO+36 mnths|
|FM||December 2021, EUMETSAT|
A review workshop will take place in late 2020 to gather an independent assessment of the outcomes of the project.